Easter trading laws still a mess


Every year at Easter a small number of hardy shop keepers ignore the Easter trading laws that generally prohibit businesses opening to conduct trade. These businesses cop fines when the Department of Internal Affairs comes knocking on their doors to find out why they are breaking the law. But defiantly with a dogged determination, they might just as well be saying to the compliance officers “See you again next year”.

To some extent I have sympathy with them as Easter is a religious holiday whose significance is obviously not relevant to all New Zealanders. It is also borne out of a genuine belief that the New Zealand trading laws surrounding Easter are out of date. And in the case of one persistent offender, gardening supplies chain Oderings it is not even about religion, but simply about the fact that a lot of people like to potter in their gardens at Easter. With plants and the weather transitioning between summer and winter, the public holiday is a good time to get their gardens ready.

I am personally not so sure that the laws are out of date, or just very poorly written. Certainly they are inconsistent in their application, and about as clear as mud in determining where stores can/cannot open. To that end I believe the Government law change that was announced in 2015 might have been good in intent, but was lousy in its application. By enabling the numerous district and city councils to determine which places shops can open or not, potentially 60 odd different bodies are going to have potentially 60 different interpretations.

Earlier blog articles have mentioned how I think the Easter trading laws in New Zealand need to change. I do not think any further change will happen under this Government. However as long as businesses such as Oderings continue to flout the law, it is worthwhile asking oneself not whether tougher laws are needed for dealing with violations, but whether the premise of the existing trading laws is correct.

Maybe Oderings has a point.

One thought on “Easter trading laws still a mess

  1. We have just had a refferendum about a flag to represent NZ. The flag with the Union Jack on it won! The Union Jack declares our ties with Great Britain, and our Queen.

    New Zealand has a Queens representative who is the Govenor General – who signs off bills passed by our Westminster system of our Governence, and who has the power to introduce a new Government, or to dismiss one. Our representatives in our Parliament primarially swear their loyalty to our Queen with their hand in the Christian Bible.
    The Queen of England rules Britain, and her Commonwealth of Nations. She is validated in her assention by the Church of England. The Church of England is a Christian Religion.
    Therefore ipso facto New Zealand is a Christian Country.
    The Church of England regards Easter as a significant religious event. Is represents the very basis of the religion – that Jesus Christ, the Son of God, died on the cross for his people, and rose again and ascended into heaven at the Right Hand of God.
    As a Christian country we surely should not sully our major Christian festival, by carrying on business activities on those religious days, but use the days to attend Church, and/or simply reflect on the significance of the religious event and its implications for us as a people in these present days. After all who does not remember the story about how Jesus entered the temple and threw out the money men.
    Lets keep the money men out of Easter

    King James Bible, Matthew 21:12
    And Jesus went into the temple of God, and cast out all them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the moneychangers, and the seats of them that sold doves,

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s