The special N.Z.-Australia relationship on the rocks

When Minister of Foreign Affairs, Gerry Brownlee went to Australia it was expected that he would convey the concerns of the New Zealand Government about Australia’s treatment of the many New Zealanders in the “Lucky Country”. Instead Mr Brownlee danced to the tune of his Australian counter part Julie Bishop.

So how did it come to this? How did the Australian-New Zealand relationship, which has been so warm and fuzzy for so long, come to this?

First off we have to ask ourtselves whether it really was that warm and fuzzy all along or whether New Zealanders had the wool pulled over our eyes. It is true that in some respects New Zealanders have easier access into Australia that other nationalities can simply only dream about. A New Zealander can simply fly to Australia, pass through customs and set about finding a job and a place to live.

But that is about where it stops. Those other nationalities have always had something we have never had: a path to Australian citizenship. Those other nationalities have had – once they have obtained Australian citizenship – access to Australian Government services, which we have never had.

So, is it possible the dream that New Zealanders have had when moving to Australia, always been that all along? A dream that they would find the greener pastures of better income, job opportunities and recreation that for whatever reason they thought could not be obtained in New Zealand? Quite possible. And worse still, despite the warning signs, we went along with it.  And in some respects, many people seem to still be happy to go along with it. I have a current colleague moving to Australia in a few weeks time and I wonder if she knows and understands that those announcements a couple of weeks ago are going to affect further – i.e. erode – New Zealanders eligibility for Australian Government assistance whilst living there.

The deterioration started in 2001, when the Government of John Howard announced significant reforms to Australian immigration law specific to New Zealanders. This was the Family and Community Services Legislation Amendment (New Zealand Citizens)Act, 2001. It blocked New Zealanders arriving after 26 February 2001 from getting Australian citizenship. It also blocked them from using social welfare services. It created an underclass of citizen living in Australia.

So, how much further are we going to let our relationship with Australia erode before we take the country that stood loyally beside us at Gallipoli and in so many other battles, to task over their treatment of us? I do not know. But we need to be careful when we eventually do. Australia, much as this treatment suggests otherwise is still our nearest and possibly our dearest neighbour and being a much larger, wealthier country. Pushing too hard for evening out the playing field might do more harm than good.

1 thought on “The special N.Z.-Australia relationship on the rocks

  1. Bill English: “What have been a set of assumptions and practices that we’ll treat each other’s citizens as if they were our citizens…we can’t assume that”

    Yes, the working assumption is dead in the water and anyone who crosses the ditch with the intention of emigrating now must fill out the requisite forms before shifting or inadvertently put their children in a poor future situation and themselves in a great deal of pain.

    Things have changed and it is now up to the NZ and Australian Governments to inform NZ’rs in no uncertain terms that there is a new World and the SCV is not for long term use. This requires a full on media educational package to prevent Kiwis being caught in a bygone era.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.