Can the Maori Party revive?

In 2009, the year after it was ousted from the New Zealand Parliament in the General Election, New Zealand First faithful gathered to do two things:

  1. Assess the damage caused by being ousted from Parliament
  2. Decide how to move forward based on the assessment of the damage

No one said it would be easy, and it was not. But New Zealand First made it happen and in 2011 picked up 8 seats. Winston Peters and Deputy Leader Barbara Stewart led six newcomers into the House of Representatives much to the chagrin of National. Nearly a year after the 2017 General Election, the Maori Party must be wondering the same thing: can it pull itself back together and if so, where to from here?

The Maori Party has many challenges lying before it. They range from the basic ones around how does a party ousted from Parliament rebuild with severely limiting resources, through to how to attract new members and whether or not the Party’s constitution is in need of an overhaul.

But first things first. Who is going to lead the party? Right now both of the co-leadership positions (Maori Party constitution requires a female and male co-leader)are vacant. Will Te Ururoa Flavell and Marama Fox want them back? Good question. If not then who will take over? There are no obvious candidates to do so at the moment as these were in many respects the two most charismatic, capable and certainly the best known of all the Maori Party leaders over the years.

The Maori Party will have significant challenges to address in terms of who does it represent. One might say that the answer is in the name, and whilst there is truth in that, when one looks at the diverse range of settings Maori find themselves in, the answer is certainly not as simple as one might want to think.

  • Will northern Maori, with issues pertaining to the Treaty of Waitangi and adherence to it by the Crown, Maori and non-Maori alike put their foot down and demand concessions from the leaders
  • Will Ngapuhi come to the table with realistic expectations about what to get out of a settlement as the last major Iwi to commence negotiations
  • Would it want a reconciliation with former member and Mana Party leader Hone Harawira, son of the notorious Titewhai Harawira?

In many respects I was not surprised that the Maori Party collapsed at the last election. Past efforts at having a Maori Party in Parliament have collapsed as well. It also did not help that a resurgent Labour feeling the Jacinda-mania warmth picked out all seven seats, having finally convinced Maori that, yes, it has learnt the lessons of the Helen Clark Government. But the major reason that the Maori Party failed at the 2017 election was that internal warring. a general failure to address issues more pressing than the Treaty of Waitangi, such as crime, joblessness, suicide and addiction rates – all the statistics no one wants to be represented in, in other words – and nine years with National, were just too much for many to stomach.

With 2011 still two year away there is still time to rebuild. But it would be wise to start the planning now.


1 thought on “Can the Maori Party revive?

  1. Thank you for raising the issue.

    As a campaign worker for MANA for the last 3 elections I know some things outsiders don’t. For the last five years since the split with the Maori Party was healed, the two have worked together on strategies whenever it was for mutual benefit. Internal polls of both sets of supporters have consistently favoured rejoining forces, but until now MANA’s bottom line of no more coalitions with National prevented it happening. It’s now very likely we will get together in the next year or two. We’re expecting Labour to be re-elected in 2020 and they’re likely to retain the Maori seats, so our next big-effort campaign will be in 2023. Maori are used to long timelines, we’ve been doing this for 150 years!

    I’m quite sure we’ll be back, and here’s why. The biggest issue that led to the formation of the Maori Party is still unchanged. Maori MP’s in mainstream parties must rely on them for re- election and are both outvoted and sidelined in caucus with no input into policy. So never mind appearances, there is no Maori voice in Parliament that isn’t muted or more often silenced by a white majority. Remember Seabed and Foreshore and a whole Maori Labour caucus who were told support the Bill or your future List positions will suffer?

    Something else makes me sure we’ll be back. Think about the long-life political parties like National and Labour. Both have an enduring support constituency – farmers, business, workers and unions. Parties that come and go don’t have that kind of homogeneous support base. Our support base is Maori, mostly homogeneous, not going away any time soon and we’re becoming more numerous. When I was born there were 140,000 of us. Now there are 600,000 and half of us haven’t reached voting age yet. Furthermore the demographers tell us that in 2050 most white Kiwis will be pensioners and most of the taxpayers supporting them will be brown! That’s a compelling reason to get all our differences sorted out long before then.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.